HC Deb 15 July 1947 vol 440 cc200-1
15. Mr. Stephen

asked the Secretary of State for War if he is aware that the decision to restrict compassionate leave to soldiers to cases where it is a question of the death, imminent death or dangerous illness of a wife, child or parent of the soldier, often causes great distress to a family in cases of the dangerous illness of a brother or sister of the soldier when such leave is refused; and whether he will take steps to extend the provision for compassionate leave in such cases when supported by medical certificates.

Mr. Bellenger

Recommendations for compassionate leave in cases of dangerous illness or imminent death have necessarily been restricted generally to the relationships of parent, wife or child. This restriction was essential owing to the number of cases which would be involved if the concession were extended to embrace a larger category. Exceptional cases, however, merit and receive exceptional consideration, and the concession is extended outside these three relationships in the case of next-of-kin or a twin, or if medical evidence is submitted that the recovery of the sick person would be materially assisted by the presence of the soldier.

Mr. Stephen

Is the right hon. Gentleman aware of the widespread feeling that in exceptional cases the War Office is taking an unnecessarily hard line?

Mr. Bellenger

No, Sir. In the overseas Commands the question of priority is decided by an all-ranks committee. I am satisfied that, on the whole, it works satisfactorily.

Mr. Sparks

In cases where death may not be imminent but is, nevertheless, certain in a period of six months or so, as in a case of cancer, is it not possible for my right hon. Friend to arrange for compassionate posting for men stationed overseas? I understand that continued compassionate leave is not acceptable.

Mr. Bellenger

The general policy now is not to make compassionate postings but to grant compassionate release.

Squadron-Leader Fleming

Where the mother's medical certificate states that it is advisable that the soldier should be brought home, will the right hon. Gentleman advise the people overseas to take notice of the medical certificate?

Mr. Bellenger

The Question does not deal with cases relating to mothers but with less close relationships.

Squadron-Leader Fleming

The right hon. Gentleman has suggested that the Question does not apply to mothers, but does it not refer to the parent of the soldier?

Mr. Bellenger

If the hon. and gallant Member will read the Question he will see that it relates to a brother or sister.