HC Deb 24 October 1944 vol 404 cc9-10
23. Mr. Tinker

asked the Secretary of State for War if he is aware that there is considerable feeling among the soldiers who joined the Army before the war in having to prove that during the period from 3rd March, 1939, they were contributing towards dependant's maintenance before they can get dependant's allowance; and will he consider removing this barrier if the soldier is making a contributory allotment now.

Sir J. Grigg

The dependants' allowance scheme was introduced in order to assist soldiers who, prior to their enlistment, had been supporting dependants to a greater extent than they could afford to continue out of their Army pay, and where, without an allowance, hardship would result to the dependant. It is an essential condition for the award of a dependant's allowance that the dependant must have been in receipt of genuine regular support or benefit from the soldier before the date on which he joined the colours. My hon. Friend's proposal would entail a complete reversal of this policy and it could not be confined to soldiers who joined before the war.

Mr. Tinker

Is my right hon. Friend aware that many men joined the Service prior to the war because of economic circumstances such as unemployment, and could not send anything to their households, and that the position is therefore difficult? Is not the time coming when the Minister should reconsider that decision?

Sir J. Grigg

That would require radical alteration of a scheme which does not affect only the Army. As my hon. Friend is no doubt aware, in cases where the circumstances of the family—that is to say of the dependants—have materially changed there is eligibility for a war service grant.

Mr. Tinker

We have made many changes during the war for the benefit of the people who are fighting for us. Will not the Minister consider this point again?

Sir J. Grigg

If my recollection serves me aright the point was carefully considered after a deputation of Members of this House met the Deputy Prime Minister, the Leader of the House and the Chancellor of the Exchequer not very many months ago.