HC Deb 19 October 1944 vol 403 cc2515-6
18. Mr. Sorensen

asked the Secretary of State for India how many Congress detainees have been released since their original detention; what conditions respecting restriction of movement or public speech and statement accompanied their release; and whether, in view of the freedom of movement and speech enjoyed by Mr. Gandhi, the remaining detainees may now enjoy at least freedom of access for visitors and freedom of publication.

Mr. Amery

The answer to the first part of the Question is, approximately, 15,000. So far as I am aware, the releases have as a rule been made unconditionally. Persons detained are allowed visits from members of their families on domestic matters. Facilities for political discussion or publication would obviously nullify the object of their detention.

Mr. Sorensen

Does it not seem inconsistent to allow so many Congress prisoners to be released without conditions, to move freely about, while others are still detained who are no worse than those who have been released? Will not the right hon. Gentleman relieve—

Mr. Speaker

That is a speech and not a question.

Mr. Sorensen

May I have an answer to the first part of my question?

Mr. Amery

It must be a matter for the judgment of the Government of India.

Forward to