HC Deb 29 March 1944 vol 398 cc1433-4
48. Mr. Woodburn

asked the Minister of Food if he will state the number of man-hours required to load, transport, unload and brew into beer any given quantity of cereals sent, under the present arrangements, to Ireland for brewing and the man-hours required to ship back the beer, compared with the man-hours required to brew the beer, in the existing English end Scottish breweries.

Colonel Llewellin

I regret that the detailed information desired by my hon. Friend is not available, but I am satisfied that the arrangement is economical in the use of United Kingdom man-power.

Mr. Woodburn

Is it not extremely wasteful in transport to take cereals to Ireland and bring beer back to this country, when it could be brewed here with very little labour?

Colonel Llewellin

We have not the man-power to-day to brew the beer here. As a matter of fact one ton of cereals produces six tons of beer, and the beer from Ireland is only shipped coastwise to the coastal districts of this country.

Mr. Mathers

Is there not something wrong when there is too much beer being brewed to be met by the man-power of this country?

Professor Savory

Is there not very considerable risk in this traffic to the lives of our seamen?

Colonel Llewellin

No, Sir. Fortuately there have recently been no losses in what I think is termed the Irish Sea.

Viscountess Astor

Is it not true that there is a shameful shortage of feed for chickens, and that Members of Parliament would rather have a good fried egg than a pint of beer?

Colonel Llewellin

My aim is to give people both eggs and beer.