§ 33. Sir William Davisonasked the Minister of Health whether, in connection with the issue of official birth certificates, he has now given further consideration to the possibility of issuing a simple certificate merely stating the date of birth of the applicant, without any additional information as to legitimacy or illegitimacy, such certificate to be issued to applicants in consideration of a nominal payment; and whether action will be taken on the lines suggested.
§ Mr. WillinkI have nothing to add to the answers I gave to my hon. Friend on 27th January and to my hon. and gallant Friend the Member for Hands-worth (Commander Locker-Lampson) on 17th February.
§ Sir W. DavisonHas the Minister ever had the pleasure of awarding a scholarship to a girl of 18 to enable her to go to a university, and of seeing her blush scarlet when she was asked to produce her birth certificate to confirm her age because it would disclose that she was illegitimate? Why should these young people be subjected to this unnecessary humiliation?
§ Mr. WillinkNo, Sir, I have never had such an opportunity, but I have twice 363 already expressed my sympathy on this matter and I have twice said that there should be a full opportunity for discussion. I have also said that the matter is one requiring legislation.
§ Captain PluggeDoes the Minister consider it right that a citizen should be compelled to divulge facts about himself which are not really required and have not been asked for?
§ Sir W. DavisonIs it not a fact that legislation would not be required in order to put this matter right in the way I suggest, and that there would be no difficulty whatever in sending an extract from the birth certificate to show the date of birth?
§ Commander Locker-LampsonWill the Minister receive a deputation on the matter, and undertake not to say "No," in advance?
§ Mr. WillinkI have twice said that I am willing to receive a deputation.