HC Deb 11 March 1943 vol 387 cc855-6
55 and 56. Miss Ward

asked the Minister of Health (1) whether, in view of several decisions not to recommend to the Ministry of Labour the deferment for national service of domestic staff, it is his policy to close down private nursing homes;

(2) whether, in view of his decision that there are too many private nursing homes in Newcastle-on-Tyne, he will give a list of other towns which he considers are in a similar position?

Mr. E. Brown

The fact that applications for deferment in individual cases are not invariably supported by my Department does not justify the conclusion which the hon. Lady has drawn. Individual applications must be considered on their merits.

Miss Ward

May I have a reply to the second Question, and will the Minister give a direct answer to the Question whether he wishes to reduce the number of nursing homes?

Mr. Brown

The answer is, "No." I said that in my reply.

Miss Ward

Has the Minister considered that as a matter of general policy, for instance, in Newcastle-on-Tyne, or does he deal with every individual case as it turns up?

Mr. Brown

All these cases for individual deferment, whether in nursing homes,

this disease for the County of Durham (administrative county and county boroughs combined) are as follow:

hospitals or anywhere else, are judged on their merits. That is the only way to deal with the matter in order to draw a fair line between the various demands for manpower.

Miss Ward

Owing to the unsatisfactory nature of the reply, I beg to give notice that I shall raise this matter on the Adjournment.

Forward to