§ 1. Mr. Snaddenasked the Secretary of State for Scotland whether his attention has been directed to the disparity which has been permitted to occur in respect of the Government's schemes for the encouragement of the breeding of hill cattle in England and Scotland; and what steps he proposes to take in order to remove existing inequality of treatment?
§ The Secretary of State for Scotland (Mr. T. Johnston)There are differences between the two schemes, and it is difficult to say whether on balance the provisions and conditions of the Scottish scheme or of the English scheme are the more favourable. But I am discussing the matter with the Executive of the Scottish National Farmers' Union, and I will be glad also to have the benefit of the hon. Member's advice.
§ Mr. SnaddenIs the right hon. Gentleman aware that as things stand at present English buyers are able to come to Scotland and outbid Scottish farmers at our store sales because of the fact that under the Scottish scheme only breeding cows are eligible, whereas in England cows, steers and heifers may qualify?
§ Mr. JohnstonAs I indicated in my answer, it is very difficult to say where the balance of advantages lies, but I shall be very glad to discuss the matter with my hon. Friend.