HC Deb 16 December 1943 vol 395 cc1663-4
16. Mr. Sorensen

asked the Secretary of State for India whether he has any report on the health of Mrs. Gandhi; and whether, as in the case of other women detainees who have been released on grounds of ill-health, Mrs. Gandhi is likely to be released from detention?

Mr. Amery

Mrs. Gandhi, who has been subject to heart attacks for some time, had two severe heart attacks at the end of November. Since then she has had one further slight attack, but although weak is reported to be better. The Government of India some time ago considered her release on grounds of health, but formed the view to which they still hold that it would be in Mrs. Gandhi's own interest to remain where she is with one of the most eminent heart specialists in India living on the premises and able to attend her at any time.

Mr. Sorensen

While also expressing the sympathy so eloquently expressed by the Secretary of State, might I ask, regarding Mrs. Gandhi, whether she has the opportunity and option of leaving if she so desires?

Mr. Amery

The question of leaving was considered, and she has been allowed to see relatives, but following medical advice it was considered that she is most securely situated where she is.

Mr. Sorensen

While thoroughly appreciating all that has been done for Mrs. Gandhi, can I take it that if the medical advisers desire it or she herself desires to leave incarceration, permission will be given to her?

Mr. Amery

I must leave that to the Government of India.

Commander Locker-Lampson

Is not the heart condition of Mrs. Gandhi worse than phlebitis?

Mr. Gallacher

Are we to take it from this reply that the strong feelings expressed by the other side of the House are only for the liberation of Fascists and not for the liberation of fighters for freedom such as the Indians?