HC Deb 02 December 1943 vol 395 cc486-7
3. Mr. Rhys Davies

asked the Minister of Labour whether he is aware that Miss Jean Price, age 19, 10, Farrant Street, Widnes, is threatened with a direction to go out to work though her grandmother living in the same house is a chronic invalid; that her sister living with them is already working under direction; that the local woman employment exchange officer who threatens the direction has stated that the grandmother could be left alone in spite of a medical certificate to the contrary; that she sat on the hardship tribunal with only one other person to determine her own direction; and will he allow one of these two sisters to remain at home to perform household duties and care for the invalid?

Mr. Bevin

This case has been reconsidered, and while circumstances remain as at present no further action will be taken to transfer Miss Jean Price to other work. I understand she is performing part-time work at a local cinema. The Women's Panel which considered the case was properly constituted, and consisted of two independent members.

Mr. Davis

I take it, then, that this woman will be left where she is for the time being.

Captain Strickland

Do I understand that an official of an employment exchange can sit in a judicial capacity on a hardship committee with only one independent member?

Mr. Bevin

No.

Captain Strickland

What is the position, then?

Mr. Bevin

If I am asked about the constitution of hardship committees, the hon. and gallant Member should put the Question on the Paper.

Captain Strickland

Did I understand the Minister to say that an employment exchange official could sit in a judicial capacity on a hardship committee?

Mr. Bevin

No.