HC Deb 28 July 1942 vol 382 cc310-1
39. Mr. McNeil

asked the Lord Advocate whether he can now make a statement on the complaints by Clyde shipyard workers against some of the directors of the yard who, the workmen allege, used wood, steel, special metals and skilled workmen to construct domestic shelters,. garden gates', and lengths of rail for a miniature railway?

Mr. Johnston

My right hon. and learned Friend has asked me to reply on his behalf. Proceedings have been taken against two directors and a foreman in respect of alleged improper use of certain materials. While these proceedings are pending the Lord Advocate is unable to make any further statement.

Mr. McNeil

Can my right hon. Friend say the stage at which the proceedings have reached? Have the men been charged? I do not think that that is in any way infringing upon the usual procedure.

Mr. Johnston

Not only were they charged but they appeared before the sheriff on 15th July, and the trial will be in September.

Mr. McNeil

Can my right hon. Friend say whether they appeared in public court, and, if they did not, why not?

Mr. Johnston

I cannot answer that Question without notice.

Mr. McKinlay

Why, when a workman takes a piece of spare wood is he prosecuted and his name broadcast, and yet the names of these people are suppressed and the public do not know who they are?

Mr. Johnston

All I can answer is that the Question did not appear on the Order Paper, and I am replying for my right hon. and learned Friend the Lord Advocate.

Mr. McNeil

Surely, it is not unreasonable to ask my right hon. Friend what stage the proceedings have reached and for him in his answer to tell us what proceedings have taken place?

Mr. Johnston

I have already answered that question and said that the men appeared before the sheriff on 15th July, and that the trial will be in September.