HC Deb 18 December 1941 vol 376 cc2056-7
11. Mr. Ammon

asked the Secretary of State for India whether, having regard to the war situation in the Far East and the threat to India arising therefrom, he will reconsider the proposals already brought to his notice for the establishment of a motor transport manufacturing industry?

Mr. Amery

I am afraid that the extension of the war has not increased the resources available for the establishment of an automobile industry in India or afforded grounds for reconsideration of a decision taken solely from the point of view of securing India's maximum contribution to the war effort.

Mr. Ammon

But surely it would be an advantage in these times to develop any sort of industry which has some relation to the war effort? The right hon. gentleman had suggestions submitted to him from India, but they would seem to have received only the most cursory consideration.

Mr. Amery

The matter has been most carefully considered, and the conclusion arrived at is that any attempt to set up this industry now would divert both labour and machinery which are more urgently needed for the war.

Mr. Ammon

Is not this another case of too long delay? This proposal was submitted months ago.

Mr. Amery

I cannot agree that there has been delay.

Mr. Silverman

Could the right hon. Gentleman say what were the considerations which led to the conclusion to which he has referred?

Mr. Amery

The proposal submitted was one for starting this industry after the war. The Government of India concluded that it could not profitably give the necessary priority in regard to the provision of machinery and labour.