HC Deb 18 March 1940 vol 358 cc1631-2
43. Mr. Robert Gibson

asked the Minister of Health whether he is aware that the manufacturing industry granted de-rating by the Act of 1929 are now prospering, with the result that the reason for such de-rating has been eradicated; and whether he will introduce legislation for the purpose of allowing these industries to resume their proper share of local government expenditure?

The Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Health (Miss Horsbrugh)

My right hon. Friend is unable to accept the conclusion reached in the first part of the Question. The second part, therefore, does not arise.

Mr. Gibson

Can the Minister explain why her right hon. Friend is not able to reach a conclusion?

Miss Horsbrugh

My right hon. Friend has not reached the same conclusion as the hon. and learned Gentleman has in the first part of his Question.

Mr. Gibson

What conclusion has he reached?

Miss Horsbrugh

A conclusion, I am informed, different from that of the hon. and learned Gentleman.

Mr. Herbert Morrison

Is the hon. Lady not aware that this de-rating legislation was brought in for the protection of heavy industry and that that protection has since been afforded by protective tariffs; and should not the system be reconsidered, on account of the circumstances having entirely changed?

Miss Horsbrugh

My right hon. Friend is considering the whole matter, but he has not come to the same conclusion as that put forward in the first part of the Question.

Mr. R. C. Morrison

Will the Minister not reconsider the matter, in view of the fact that every town has thousands of small shopkeepers who are unable to pay their rates?

Miss Horsbrugh

Again, my right hon. Friend is aware of the matter, and it will be considered.

Mr. Gibson

Does the Minister propose to give de-rating to small shopkeepers?