HC Deb 04 May 1939 vol 346 cc2039-40
9. Mr. Sorensen

asked the Minister of Labour whether he is aware that a workman has been refused unemployment benefit because his loss of employment was due to action arising from his conscientious pacifist convictions; and will he take action in this matter?

Mr. E. Brown

No case of this kind has been brought to my notice, but I will make inquiries if the hon. Member will be good enough to send me particulars. I would, however, point out that the decision whether or not benefit should be paid in a particular case rests with the independent statutory authorities.

Mr. Sorensen

While appreciating the reply of the right hon. Gentleman and assuring him that I will send him full information, can I be assured that some indication will be given to courts of referees and similar bodies that this kind of persecution must not go on?

Mr. Brown

Until I know that such things happen, I cannot give any indication at all.

Brigadier-General Sir Alfred Knox

Is it in the interests of the other contributors to the Fund, and of the State, that men should be given unemployment benefit for refusing work of national importance?

Mr. Brown

I cannot be drawn into giving an answer of a general kind until I am sure what is the substantial point.