HC Deb 06 October 1938 vol 339 c479
Mr. Boothby

On a point of Order. I should like to call attention to a paragraph which appears in the "Times" this morning, which I will read: Domestically much interest has been attached to the strength and intentions of the dissident Conservatives, but it now seems that they are stronger in quality than in number. They are expected to number about 25, and will register their dissent by abstaining from voting on the confidence motion. They are believed to include Mr. Churchill, Mr. Eden, Lord Cranborne, Sir Sidney Herbert, Mr. J. P. L. Thomas, Mr. Cartland, and Mr. Law. They are to some degree indignant that their quota of debating time has now been exhausted, and that no more of them will be allowed to speak to-day. I do not know whether the question of Privilege arises, but I should like to ask for your guidance, Mr. Speaker. It is quite clear that this paragraph contains a very grave reflection upon your impartiality, which will be justifiably resented by hon. Members on both sides of the House.

Mr. Speaker

I do not think that we ought to treat this matter so seriously as to make it a matter of Privilege, but I should say that it is very unfortunate that a pronouncement of that kind should be made regarding my action as to which Members I have selected as having caught my eye. It has been made without any foundation of fact. Newspapers have very wide circulation, and quite a wrong impression may be given of the action of the Chair by statements of this kind. The statement had no authority at all.

Mr. Thorne

Call upon them for an apology to-morrow.

Forward to