HC Deb 17 May 1938 vol 336 cc195-7
6. Mr. McGovern

asked the Secretary of State for Scotland whether his attention has been drawn to the sentence of 12 months passed on Mrs. Laurie, 43, Denbeck Street, Shettleston, for the murder of her son and attempted suicide; whether he is aware that she was confined to the Royal Infirmary for one month and Duke Street prison for two months; and whether he will inquire further into her case with a view to exercising his right of clemency to Mrs. Laurie in view of her serious mental and financial position previous to her grave act?

Lieut.-Colonel Colville

As regards the first two parts of the question, I am aware that the woman referred to was sentenced to 12 months' imprisonment for culpable homicide on 5th April, and that prior to her conviction she was detained in the Glasgow Royal Infirmary and Duke Street Prison for about one month and two months, respectively. A medical report obtained by me shows that Mrs. Laurie's mental and physical condition have improved under the treatment which she is receiving in prison, and, after careful consideration, I have reached the conclusion that I would not be justified in advising her release at the present time The case will, however, be reviewed periodically.

Mr. McGovern

Will the right hon. and gallant Gentleman review this case again, and take into consideration the fact that this woman is suffering from a very severe mental and financial strain which brought about the tragedy; that she has six young children in the home; and that one of these children is lying in hospital with tuberculosis? Are not these circumstances sufficient to give the right hon. and gallant Gentleman reason for an act of clemency?

Lieut.-Colonel Colville

I have said that on the information before me I do not think I am justified in advising her release at the present time, but I shall review the case periodically, and shall bear in mind, in that review, the point that the hon. Member has raised and other relevant circumstances.

Mr. McGovern

Will the Secretary of State be prepared to discuss with me privately some points in relation to the case?

Lieut.-Colonel Colville

indicated assent.