HC Deb 12 July 1938 vol 338 c1114
59. Mr. Logan

asked the Minister of Health why Thomas Fisher, of 10, Hutton Street, after being out of Calder-stones institution five years, was recalled; and is he aware that the doctor said he could be considered for release if he had a permanent job?

The Parliamentary Secretary to the Ministry of Health (Mr. Bernays)

I am informed that the authorities at Calder-stones recalled the patient because questions had arisen as to the suitability of the occupation and the adequacy of the supervision available at his home. The Board of Control, however, on 21st June last asked the committee to reconsider the matter and to furnish their observations on the suitability of Mr. Fisher for discharge. As a result, it has been decided to discharge the patient.

Mr. Logan

Does not the hon. Gentleman think it time that investigation was made into these cases, as it is only when information is brought to this House that these cases ought to be discharged and that this kind of irregularity ought not to exist at all, that action is taken; and must it not be understood among the ordinary rank and file of unemployed people that Bedlam is natural for them to occupy their time in? Will he inquire into these conditions?

Mr. Bernays

My right hon. Friend appreciates the hon. Member's anxiety that these patients on licence should not be recalled unnecessarily. The Board of Control have in fact issued a circular, and my right hon. Friend is in communication with the authorities concerned.

Mr. Logan

Will the hon. Gentleman investigate in regard to this institution and examine the officials, to see whether they are all right?