HC Deb 01 December 1938 vol 342 cc579-80
30. Mr. Silkin

asked the Home Secretary whether he is aware that Mr. Alfred William Green has instituted within the past 12 months 12 actions or more in the High Court as a common informer against different persons claiming penalties for alleged breaches of the Sunday Observance Act, 1780; and, as the use of the common informer is an archaic and unsatisfactory method of invoking the law, will he consider setting up a committee to inquire into the whole question of common informers?

Sir S. Hoare

I agree that there are objections to a system by which penalties or part of the penalties imposed for breaches of the law are payable to an informer; but I do not think it is necessary to set up a committee to review this system. It is already the practice when statutes authorising this system are brought under review by amending legislation to substitute penalty provisions in modern form.

Mr. Silkin

Will the right hon. Gentleman consider dealing with the Sunday Observance Act, 1780, in the near future?

Sir S. Hoare

Even so, I do not think a committee would help us much in finding a solution to these difficulties.

Mr. Silkin

Will the right hon. Gentleman give it his consideration without a committee?