HC Deb 17 March 1937 vol 321 cc2075-7
Rear-Admiral Sir Murray Sueter

At the time of Private Business to-day, when the Great Western Railway Bill was called, many Members called out "Object," both here and in other quarters of the House. May I ask you, Mr. Speaker, whether that Bill went through?

Mr. Perkins

I was one of those Members who shouted "Object" as loudly as I could. May I ask whether it is in order for the Clerk at the Table to push a Bill of this nature through against the obvious wish of the House?

Mr. Speaker

I cannot allow the hon. Member to cast a reflection on the Clerks at the Table. As regards the point raised by the hon. and gallant Member for Hertford (Sir M. Sueter), I heard some objections raised before the Title of the Bill was read out, but after it had been read out at the Table I heard no objection, and I concluded that those objections had been withdrawn.

Lord Apsley

I was one of those Members who objected. I heard objections coming prematurely from the other side of the House, and I did not myself object then, but when the Clerk at the Table read out the Title of the Bill I did call out "Object" quite loudly, and I heard other Members on this side object, too.

Mr. Lyons

I desire to associate myself with what my Noble Friend has just said. The objection was put beforehand and also at the proper time.

Mr. Speaker

We cannot go back on what we have already done. If it is desired to raise any further objection, it can be done on the Third Reading.

Forward to