HC Deb 04 February 1937 vol 319 cc1748-9
21. Mr. T. Williams

asked the Secretary of State for the Home Department whether he will take an early opportunity to review the sentences passed at the Worksop court on Howarth miners for alleged breaches of the peace; and, in view of the circumstances obtaining in the area where a strike is in progress, will he consider remitting part of the sentences?

Sir J. Simon

The Home Secretary is not authorised to act as a court of appeal for the purpose of reviewing sentences. My duty is limited to considering whether in any particular case there are special grounds which would justify me in advising that the prerogative of mercy should be exercised. I know of no such grounds in the cases to which the hon. Member refers.

Mr. Williams

Has the right hon. Gentleman examined these cases at all, and, if so, is he not aware that the crime of these men was merely a minor indiscretion; and for the purpose of creating "sweet reasonableness" in the district; and if he has not reviewed these cases, will he do so with a view to exercising clemancy?

Sir J. Simon

I have looked at the schedule which contains all the cases and the punishments which were inflicted by the court. I have read some material about the cases but I will gladly look into the matter further.

Mr. Lawson

May I ask the right hon. Gentleman to give the legal position in this area his special attention as the owner of the colliery concerned is chairman of the county council and is in very close touch with the chief constable?

Hon. Members

Order.