HC Deb 06 December 1937 vol 330 cc1-2
1. Major-General Sir Alfred Knox

asked the Under-Secretary of State for India what decision has been arrived at in India regarding the location of the statue of General Neill, lately removed from the Mount Road, Madras, by order of the local Congress Ministry?

The Under-Secretary of State for India (Lord Stanley)

The location of this statue is a matter which is entirely within the discretion of the Madras Government. But for the information of my hon. and gallant Friend, I would draw his atten- tion to the statement of the Prime Minister of Madras that, while the Government had decided to remove the statue from its present site, it was not their desire that it should leave India, but that, on the contrary, it was their intention to preserve it with care and with respect.

Sir A. Knox

Can the Noble Lord say what site will be given to this statue in India?

Lord Stanley

No, Sir. I have not that information.

Sir A. Knox

Is it not within the power of the Governor to issue instructions to prevent an action like the removal of a statue, which is likely to hurt the feelings and prestige of Europeans?

Lord Stanley

It is entirely within the discretion of the Madras Government.

Mr. Wedgwood Benn

In view of that answer, Mr. Speaker, might I ask whether a matter of this kind, which, as the Noble Lord has said, is entirely within the discretion of the Madras Government, ought to form the subject of question and answer here?

Mr. Speaker

Probably it ought not, but it is difficult to decide beforehand whether the question is one for which the Government is responsible. The Noble Lord has answered quite correctly, that it is not.

Back to
Forward to