HC Deb 03 March 1936 vol 309 c1161
6. Mr. SHINWELL

asked the Secretary for Mines the estimated additional employment in the coal-mining industry if a six-hour day came into operation; and the estimated increase in the cost of production?

Captain CROOKSHANK

So many unknown and incalculable factors enter into the question that I am not prepared to give an estimate of either figure.

Mr. SHINWELL

Is it not possible for the hon. and gallant Gentleman to have an analysis made of the position and to furnish the House with the particulars?

Captain CROOKSHANK

No, Sir. I have just said that there are so many unknown and incalculable factors that I cannot do it.

Mr. SHINWELL

If I submit to the hon. and gallant Gentleman some suggestions on the point, will he consider them?

Captain CROOKSHANK

The Department will always consider anything that the hon. Gentleman submits.

Mr. T. SMITH

Does not the hon. and gallant Gentleman think that this subject warrants investigation by the Department in view of the decreasing number of coal miners?