HC Deb 20 July 1936 vol 315 cc24-5
45. Mr. HENDERSON STEWART

asked the Prime Minister whether his attention has been called to the proceedings in Committee of Supply on Scottish Estimates on Tuesday, 14th July, when, by arrangements between parties and Scottish Members, speeches were limited to 15 minutes each, as a result of which no less than 28 Members were able to take part in the Debate; and whether, in view of the success of the experiment, he will take steps, by Amendment of the Standing Orders or otherwise, to extend this practice in future Debates?

The PRIME MINISTER (Mr. Baldwin)

Yes, Sir, my attention has been called to the arrangements made by Scottish Members during the recent Debate on Scottish Estimates. I have on several occasions informed the House that, in my opinion, the most effective way to limit the time of speeches is by a voluntary arrangement by right hon. and hon. Members themselves. I welcome the experiment made by Scottish Members of all parties, and venture to express the hope that it will be followed by hon. Members on other occasions.

Mr. MATHERS

Has the Prime Minister taken note of the fact that the hon. Member for East Fife (Mr. Henderson Stewart) who puts the question was one of the very few who exceeded the time limit by more than one minute for winding up?

Mr. STEWART

Would the Prime Minister also bear in mind that the reason of my exceeding the time limit was that I was interrupted for four minutes by the Opposition?

Mr. MAXTON

In considering this matter, will the Prime Minister bear in mind also that there are some nations who think that government is better carried out if the speeches of Members of Parliament are cut out altogether?