HC Deb 27 March 1934 vol 287 c1802
20. Mr. MANDER

asked the Secretary of State for Dominion Affairs if he has any information with regard to the proposal to abolish the Senate in the Irish Free State; whether this would be regarded as a breach of the Anglo-Irish Treaty; and whether the British Government were consulted before the introduction of the Measure?

Mr. J. H. THOMAS

I have seen statements in the Press with regard to the introduction of a Bill to abolish the Senate in the Irish Free State, but I have not seen the text of the Bill, and I would prefer not to make any statement until I have had an opportunity of doing so. The answer to the last part of the question is in the negative.

Mr. MAXTON

Surely the Irish Free State have the right to self-govern merit nowadays, and does the right hon. Gentleman suggest that they are not entitled to govern their own country in their own way?

Mr. THOMAS

I have not suggested anything. I have merely answered the question.

Mr. SPEAKER

Mr. Chorlton.

Mr. MAXTON

Am I not entitled to ask ordinary supplementary questions of the Dominions Secretary that would be permissible in the case of other secretaries?

Mr. SPEAKER

Certainly, but as far as I can see, the hon. Member received an answer.