65. Mr. R. RICHARDSONasked the Minister of Labour whether he is aware that the Regulation disqualifying aliens for the receipt of uncovenanted employment benefit is having the effect of disqualifying men who have lived all their lives in this country: that, for instance, many members of the Cigar Makers' and Tobacco Workers' Union are technically aliens, but have lived in this country for upwards of 30 years; that they are unemployed now for the first time after many years' continuous' employment, and that some of them have lost sons in the War; and whether he will consider the advisability of removing the disqualification imposed upon aliens, or, at least, limit the disqualification to aliens whose domicile in this country has been of short duration?
Dr. MACNAMARAHaving regard to the limited sums available for the payment of uncovenanted benefit, it was decided that such benefit cannot be 2275 allowed to aliens other than British born wives or widows of aliens. This rule has been modified so as to allow benefit to aliens who have served in His Majesty's Forces. I am afraid I cannot see my way to allow any further modification. I should add that aliens are in no way disqualified on account of nationality for the receipt of covenanted benefit, that is, benefit based upon contributions.
Mr. R. RICHARDSONIs the right hon. Gentleman not aware these people will then fall on the local rates, and that it amounts to the same thing in the end?
Dr. MACNAMARAWhatever they pay they will get the benefit. We are asked to give them uncovenanted benefit.