HC Deb 09 February 1932 vol 261 cc651-2
43. Mr. PIKE

asked the Secretary for Mines whether he has now any further statement to make respecting the use in coal mines of automatic gas alarms; and whether any decision has been made regarding the compulsory use of a minimum number of these appliances in British coal mines?

66. Mr. T. WILLIAMS

asked the Secretary for Mines whether he has yet interviewed representatives of the Mining Association, Miners' Federation, National Association of Colliery Managers, and the Deputies' Association on the question of gas alarms; and has he any statement to make on the subject?

Mr. ISAAC FOOT

Meetings have been held for discussion of this difficult problem with representatives of each of the four associations named in the second question. There are still substantial differences of opinion, but I have been asked to carry the discussions further, and I believe it will serve a useful purpose to do so. In the meantime, I am not able to make any further statement.

Mr. WILLIAMS

In view of the frequency of these explosions, all due more or less to fire damp, either by accumulation or otherwise, will the hon. Gentleman try to expedite this inquiry?

Mr. FOOT

I do not know of any recent explosion that can be said to be associated with the subject raised by this question, but I regard the matter as being important, and every step will be taken to secure expeditious inquiry.

Mr. D. GRENFELL

Does not the hoe. Gentleman admit that all recent explosions are due to the non-discovery of inflammable gas, and that the use of the automatic gas alarms might have discovered it?

Mr. FOOT

I have made express inquiries, and I am told that no recent explosion is one which can be attributed to the absence of automatic gas detectors.

Mr. WILLIAMS

Is it not the case that in all the reports of His Majesty's Chief Inspector following recent explosions the information is that the explosions occurred because of accumulations of fire damp, which some use of automatic alarms may have discovered?

Mr. FOOT

"May."