HC Deb 24 September 1931 vol 256 cc1807-8
30. Sir C. RAWSON

asked the Home Secretary why permission is refused by the Governor of His Majesty's Prison at Parkhurst for a heart specialist to visit a prisoner, a previous patient, who is suffering from angina pectoris; and whether it is possible to make any exception?

Sir H. SAMUEL

The prisoner in question has been free from heart attacks during his sentence. He is receiving all necessary medical care and attention and, if necessary, the prison medical officer could call in a specialist. In these circumstances, there is no reason for taking any excxeptional course.

Sir C. RAWSON

As the cost of the specialist will not fall on the public funds, is there any reason why this man should not be examined by his own doctor who is quite familiar with his case.

Sir H. SAMUEL

If that were done in one case, it would have to be done in others, and there is no special reason why an exception should be made in this case.

Sir C. RAWSON

The only reason is life and death. Could not the right hon. Gentleman make an exception in this case?

Sir H. SAMUEL

This patient is not ill, and has not been subject to any heart attacks during his imprisonment. The medical officer is carefully watching the case, and, as I have said, if there is any reason of life and death, a specialist will be called in.

Mr. MARJORIBANKS

Is the right hon. Gentleman waiting for a heart attack?