HC Deb 07 May 1930 vol 238 cc943-4
20. Captain BALFOUR

asked the First Lord of the Admiralty the number of the ship s complement of His Majesty's Ship "Ceres" who served in the Mediterranean during 1928 and 1929 and who, during such service in that ship, or subsequently, have developed tuberculosis?

Mr. ALEXANDER

The numbers of cases of pulmonary tuberculosis occurring in His Majesty's Ship "Ceres" were two during 1928 and three during 1929, whilst she was in commission on the Mediterranean Station. It is not known how many of the personnel, if any, of His Majesty's Ship "Ceres" developed pulmonary tuberculosis subsequently to their leaving that ship, and to ascertain this would involve a large amount of research such as I should not feel justified in ordering in the absence of very special reasons.

Captain BALFOUR

May I ask whether five cases of tuberculosis in one ship is considered by naval medical authorities as far more than the usual number?

Mr. ALEXANDER

The number of such cases varies a great deal in the same type of ship, but I am satisfied that the general health of the Navy in regard to this type of disease has been maintained during the last two years.

Captain BALFOUR

In this particular ship?

Major Sir BERTRAM FALLE

May I ask how many of these men were given pensions on account of their disability?

Mr. ALEXANDER

Obviously, I should require notice of that question.

Dr. VERNON DAVIES

Can the right hon. Gentleman say whether these were contact cases?

Mr. ALEXANDER

I must ask hon. Members to please give me notice of questions like that.