HC Deb 31 October 1929 vol 231 c307
29. Mr. E. BROWN

asked the Minister of Labour if her Department has received an application from the Leith Dock Commission with regard to two accelerated schemes for dock extension; and, if so, whether the schemes are to be treated on a revenue or non-revenue basis or if any new financial arrangement is proposed?

Miss BONDFIELD

The answer to the first part of the question is in the affirmative. The schemes cannot, I am afraid, be assisted on a non-revenue-producing basis, and no new financial arrangement beyond the terms already offered to the Commissioners is proposed.

Mr. BROWN

Is the right hon. Lady aware that this Commission, in common with other authorities, has been asked by the present Government to produce a new scheme, and that the answer she has given is precisely the same as was given by the previous Government?

Miss BONDFIELD

I think the terms offered to the Commissioners are quite reasonable and fair.

Mr. BROWN

Is the right hon. Lady not aware that this is not a private enterprise Commission at all, but a statutory Commission; and why should it be classified in the category of a revenue-producing undertaking, seeing that it does not produce any revenue for private persons? Will the right hon. Lady give it her consideration again?