HC Deb 31 October 1929 vol 231 cc296-7
4. Sir GERALD HURST

asked the Minister of Labour whether she is aware that her undertaking of the 13th September to seek the advice of the Musicians' Union before giving foreign bands permission to enter England has not been kept; that advice was not sought as to Ben Bernie's American band on the day it landed (1st September) and as to Chez Taglioni band eight days after it landed (16th September); and if the undertaking will be kept in future?

Miss BONDFIELD

For several years it has been the practice of my Department to consult the Musicians' Union in cases of doubt or difficulty, and an undertaking was given on 13th September that this practice would be adhered to. It was also arranged with the Union on 8th October that they should be informed of all applications for permits, whether giving rise to doubt or not, so that they could make representations if they so desired. The admission of the two bands mentioned in the question did not call for consultation with the Union under the earlier practice and occurred before the supplementary undertaking was given.

Sir G. HURST

Does the right hon. Lady realise that to encourage foreign competition in the home market only leads to unemployment?

Miss BONDFIELD

I have given the closest attention to this matter, and I am satisfied that the policy we are pursuing, which is a continuous policy, I may say, with the exception of the under taking of 8th October, is really assisting British musicians.

Mr. DAY

Is it a condition before these permits are granted that an equal number of British musicians shall be employed?

Miss BONDFIELD

Yes, that is one of the conditions.

Commander WILLIAMS

Then the right hon. Lady does not believe in unlimited competition?

5. Sir GEORGE HAMILTON

asked the Minister of Labour if she will consider the prevention, so far as ever possible, of foreign musicians from coming into this country, as many British musicians will be losing their engagements owing to the use of sound cinematographs?

Miss BONDFIELD

Yes, Sir. I have examined the Department's practice regarding the issue of permits for musicians, and am satisfied that it limits the entry of foreign musicians to the fullest extent which is justifiable.