HC Deb 02 May 1929 vol 227 cc1688-9
4. Viscount SANDON

asked the Home Secretary whether he will consider arrangements whereby prisoners whose crime involved pecuniary loss to anyone can be made to do work of a marketable character, from which the financial proceeds can go to the parties who have previously suffered such losses until the whole of them are worked off?

Sir W. JOYNSON-HICKS

Suggestions of this kind have been frequently considered, but there are many difficulties, including the consideration that when from the value of a prisoner's labour is deducted the cost of his maintenance and supervision, there is no margin for compensation to injured parties.

Viscount SANDON

Is it not a fact that it would be easier for the State to bear these losses than many poor people who are robbed and get no return?

Sir W. JOYNSON-HICKS

I have told my Noble Friend of the initial difficulty. If he likes to come to see me I can explain a good many other difficulties in the matter.