HC Deb 14 March 1929 vol 226 c1264
38. Sir R. THOMAS

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer whether, in cases where shopkeepers and trades have suffered losses as the result of street explosions or bursting water mains, and where liability cannot be attached to any particular public or private authority, he will consider the question of allocating some grant-in-aid towards the assistance of such financial sufferers from circumstances beyond their control?

Mr. SAMUEL

I cannot undertake to assume any liability on the part of the taxpayer in such cases.

Sir R. THOMAS

Can the Financial Secretary give the reasons?

Mr. SAMUEL

The hon. Member asks whether the Chancellor of the Exchequer will consider the question of allocating some grant-in-aid towards the assistance of such financial sufferers for circumstances beyond their control where the liability cannot be attached to any particular authority. That is a very strong order, and the liability is one which could not be placed on the taxpayer.

Mr. TAYLOR

Will the Financial Secretary stimulate a revolt among the back benches on the Government side to force the hands of the Cabinet in this matter?