HC Deb 07 May 1928 vol 217 cc20-1
50. Captain GARRO-JONES

asked the Minister of Transport whether he will publish, in so far as they relate to London, a summary of the representations received up to 3rd May from five local councils and four associations on the subject of increased passenger fares, together with the full replies of the companies concerned?

Colonel ASHLEY

When I have received and considered the replies of the companies concerned, I propose, in ordinary course, to communicate with the authorities from whom I have received representations.

Mr. DAY

Can the right hon. Gentleman say how many replies he has received up to now?

Colonel ASHLEY

I think, none, but I hope to get the most important one tomorrow.

Captain GARRO-JONES

Will the right hon. Gentleman communicate to the authorities the replies he receives from the companies?

Colonel ASHLEY

No doubt my communications will be almost entirely based on the replies I receive from the companies.

Captain GARRO-JONES

Is there any reason why there should be secrecy maintained in these matters? Cannot the right hon. Gentleman undertake to publish the replies he receives?

Colonel ASHLEY

There is nothing to prevent these five local authorities and four associations sending to the newspapers the applications they have sent to me.

Mr. CRAWFURD

Will it be possible to say what additional toll has been extracted from the public by this additional monopoly that has been created?

Colonel ASHLEY

That has nothing to do with the question.

Mr. R. MORRISON

In effect, does it not mean that there is only one omnibus company concerned?

Colonel ASHLEY

I think the London General Omnibus Company, of course, is easily the predominant company concerned.

Mr. THURTLE

Does the right hon. Gentleman not realise that what we want to know is what the companies have to say in defence of this raising of the fares, and cannot he have the text of that defence published?

Colonel ASHLEY

If and when the local authorities make proper application to me to adjudicate in relation to the matter, I will go into the whole matter, and no doubt the decision that I come to will be made public.