HC Deb 06 December 1927 vol 211 cc1185-6
66. Captain WALLACE

asked the Minister of Transport if he is aware that the borough of Hornsey can generate electricity at a cost of ½d. per unit as against the proposed charge of 63d. per unit under the south-east England electricity scheme; and if he will undertake to hold a public inquiry before adopting a scheme which will increase the price to the consumer?

Colonel ASHLEY

I must not be taken as accepting the figures put forward by my hon. Friend as comparable, but I would refer him to the provisions of Section 14 of the Electricity (Supply) Act, from which he will see that a station cannot be compulsorily closed down unless the Central Electricity Board are in a position to supply at a cheaper rate. Parliament has placed on the Board the duty of investigating schemes submitted to them, and I understand that they are at present discussing in detail representations with the undertakers concerned.

Mr. T. WILLIAMS

Is the right hon. Gentleman not aware that the Central Electricity Board have insisted upon a power station being closed down where it has been possible under local people to produce electricity cheaper than that produced by the Electricity Board?

Colonel ASHLEY

I cannot accept for a moment the statement of the hon. Member.

Mr. WILLIAMS

Is the right hon. Gentleman not aware that a case was brought to his notice referring to the Mexborough Urban District Council station?

Captain WALLACE

Who is going to be the official authority to say which can produce at the cheaper rate?

Colonel ASHLEY

The Central Electricity Board under the Act of last year.

Mr. HARDIE

Is it not a fact that these grievances and these questions are due to the working of the Act which was passed by the present Government?

Colonel ASHLEY

Yes, but I do not agree with the figures put forward by the hon. Member.

Forward to