HC Deb 10 May 1926 vol 195 cc693-4
Sir N. GRATTAN-DOYLE

I beg to ask leave to move the Adjournment of the House for the purpose of discussing a definite matter of urgent public importance, namely, "to take into consideration the serious effect upon the country of the following statements made in this House on Thursday last by the hon. Member for Newcastle East (Mr. Connolly): That the O.M.S. has broken down in Newcastle; that the trade unions had been requested to take over the essential services, and have done so on condition that the soldiers and the special constabulary be withdrawn; that these conditions were agreed to, and that the trade unions are now carrying on successfully; to inquire into the truth or otherwise of these statements, and, if found to be without foundation, to take such measures as may be necessary to counteract their pernicious effect."

Mr. SPEAKER

That is hardly a Motion which in any way complies with Standing Order No. 10. It is an allegation or a dispute with another hon. Member of the House; it is not a matter concerning any dereliction of duty on the part of the Government.

Sir N. GRATTAN-DOYLE

I accept your ruling, Mr. Speaker, but may I ask your ruling on this point, for the information of the House, whether you have any power or authority in the present crisis to deal with any bon. Member who makes statements in this House which are unfounded and prejudicial?

Mr. SPEAKER

Certainly not. Hon. Members come here, and take sides on questions which often differ, and differ very materially. I have no jurisdiction, and no desire to prevent hon. Members being heard.

Mr. CONNOLLY

rose—

Mr. SPEAKER

I have already allowed the hon. Member to put his side of the case, and the matter must remain there for the moment.

Mr. CONNOLLY

May I ask whether, in your opinion, the statement that has been made by the hon. Member does not contain an innuendo against myself to which I am entitled to reply?

Mr. SPEAKER

I called upon the hon. Member immediately the statement was made to put his side of the case, and he has done so. I cannot allow further proceedings. I have allowed both sides to state their case.