§ 41. Mr. MacKENZIE LIVINGSTONEasked the Minister of Health if he is aware that in the draft Rules of 17th March, 1925, on preservatives in foods there is a list of prohibited coal-tar products which gives the impression that all other such products may be used; and will he take steps to lay down the quantities of lead and arsenic permitted in such compounds, and thus carry out the recommendations of the Committee?
§ The PARLIAMENTARY SECRETARY to the MINISTRY of HEALTH (Sir Kingsley Wood)Yes, Sir. The effect of the Regulations, as drafted, is that all coal-tar colours which are not included in the Schedule may be used in food until they are shown to be injurious to health. Although lead and arsenic are occasionally present in coal-tar products, my right hon. Friend is advised that the percentage of those substances liable to be introduced into foodstuffs through this medium is so minute that it is unnecessary to extend the scope of the Regulations in the direction suggested.
§ Mr. H. WILLIAMSHas the Parliamentary Secretary received any protests against these Regulations?
§ Sir K. WOODYes, Sir. We have received protests and assents.
§ Lieut.-Colonel JAMESShall we have any opportunity to debate this?
§ Sir K. WOODI think the hon. and gallant Gentleman should give notice of that question.
§ 50. Mr. GERALD HURSTasked the Minister of Health whether he is aware of the alarm occasioned to the confectionery, bakery, and allied trades by the draft Regulations as to the use of preservatives and colouring matter in articles of food; whether he is aware of the strong scientific evidence published against prohibition of boracic acid and against the new Rules as to liquid eggs, butter, margarine, and cream; and if the Regulations can be held up until the House can consider their propriety?
§ Sir K. WOODMy right hon. Friend has received representations from these trades and I am arranging to meet a deputation. My right hon. Friend is satisfied that the scientific evidence regarding the effect of boric acid was thoroughly considered by the Departmental Committee on Preservatives in Food. My right hon. Friend is desirous of giving the fullest consideration to the views of all parties concerned, and thinks the hon. Member will agree that that end will be secured by the discussion of the draft with representatives of trade bodies and others before the regulations are made and laid before Parliament.
§ Mr. HARDIEIs the hon. Gentleman aware that last week a member who got a tin of boric-treated eggs into the House afterwards put it on a cast-iron umbrella-stand downstairs, and that it is eating the cast-iron away?
§ Sir K. WOODNo, Sir; but I will inspect it.
§ Major CRAWFURDWill the right hon. Gentleman ensure that the views of the representatives of medical opinion are taken?
§ Sir K. WOODI will consider that.