HC Deb 16 July 1925 vol 186 cc1509-11
11. Mr. MacKENZIE LIVINGSTONE

asked the Home Secretary whether he has called for and received a Report on the allegations made at the Central Criminal Court this week against the conduct of the police at Vine Street police station; and, if so, what are its contents?

Sir W. JOYNSON-HICKS

Yes, Sir. The Commissioner of Police has asked me to direct an independent inquiry into the action of the police in this case. I concur in his recommendation, and have given directions accordingly, and I am glad to say my right hon. and learned Friend the Member for Cambridge University (Mr. Rawlinson) has accepted my invitation to hold the inquiry.

Mr. HAYES

Will the officers concerned in this matter be allowed to be represented?

Sir W. JOYNSON-HICKS

Perhaps the hon. Gentleman will put that question later. I only heard of the case two or three days ago, when it was finished in the Court. I at once communicated with the Commissioner of Police. I then communicated with my right hon. Friend the Member for Cambridge University, who yesterday afternoon very kindly consented to hold an inquiry. I wish, necessarily, to see him and discuss the method in which the inquiry will be held, but I have no doubt that every arrangement will be made for every one concerned being represented.

Colonel DAY

Will the inquiry be held in public?

Lieut.-Colonel JAMES

Will the inquiry be confined within the narrow limits of the particular case, or, will a general inquiry be made?

Sir W. JOYNSON-HICKS

I think for the moment, certainly, that it should be confined to the narrow limits of the individual case. So far, however, as I know at present there is no general charge levied against the police. Therefore, there would be nothing to inquire upon in that respect. With respect to the suggestion of holding the inquiry in public I have a view on that, but I think until I have consulted my right hon. Friend I prefer to say nothing.

Mr. HAYES

Will the evidence be taken on oath?

Sir W. JOYNSON-HICKS

To all these questions I could have said, by way of reply, that I would make a statement later. I thought it desirable in the interest of the police and the public to make at the earliest moment the announcement that the inquiry will take place. I am sure the House will give me time to consult my right hon. Friend before saying anything further.

Mr. MacKENZIE LIVINGSTONE

Surely the Minister might decide whether this should be a public or private inquiry? [HON. MEMBERS: "Order, order!"]