HC Deb 20 February 1924 vol 169 c1722
14. Mr. THURTLE

asked the Parliamentary Secretary to the Admiralty whether he is aware that the late 1st Class Stoker George M. Thornhill, of H.M.S. "Raleigh," who lost his life in endeavouring to save the lives of his shipmates at the wreck of the "Raleigh," was, at the time of his death, making a weekly allowance of 25s. to his invalid mother and whether, in these circumstances, a pension can be granted to the mother as some compensation to her for the loss of income she has suffered through the death of her son?

Mr. AMMON

This case has been most carefully investigated, and the fact that Stoker Thornhill made an allowance of 25s. a week to his mother was fully appreciated at the time her application for a pension was under consideration. The Regulations governing pensions to parents of seamen (or soldiers or airmen) whose deaths are due to the Service do not pro vide for the award of assistance when the father is alive and earning normal wages, and I regret that it has consequently not been practicable to make any award to Mrs. Thornhill.

Mr. THURTLE

Does my hon. Friend realise that the refusal of a pension in this case means that the mother of this very gallant seaman has been seriously penalised by the heroic action of her son?

Mr. HARDIE

Is it to be the policy of this Government, in any case like this, that people are to be forced into a pauperised position?

Mr. AMMON

This Government and other Governments must and can operate only within the Regulations that are in force.

Mr. HARDIE

Can the hon. Gentleman state that this Government is going to make a promise now to change these things?