HC Deb 14 February 1924 vol 169 cc999-1000
46. Sir J. MARRIOTT

asked the Prime Minister whether the Government propose to set up again a Select Committee on Estimates; and, if so, whether they propose to give to that Committee the powers proposed by the Select Committee on National Expenditure, 1918?

Mr. CLYNES

His Majesty's Government propose to ask the House to reappoint the Estimates Committee on the lines adopted in recent years.

Captain BENN

Does the right hon. Gentleman not think that in view of the changed distribution of parties in this House wider powers should be given to this Committee so that they can guide the Committee of Supply?

Mr. CLYNES

The Government have not yet had time to reach a decision on the question of the powers referred to.

Viscount CURZON

Will the right hon. Gentleman give consideration to the appointment of a Permanent Secretary to this Committee?

Mr. PRINGLE

Would it not be competent for the House, which is now free, to modify the terms of reference to the Committee, as it pleases?

Mr. LEIF JONES

Does the right hon. Gentleman not realise that the Committee on Estimates can be of little value unless it is armed with the powers which the Committee on National Expenditure asked for in 1918?

Mr. CLYNES

As I have said, the question of powers has to be considered.