HC Deb 08 March 1920 vol 126 c904
59. Mr. W. CARTER

asked the Minister of Transport whether he has come to a decision on the question of reopening the line between Sutton Junction and Sutton Town, Notts, that was closed owing to the war?

Mr. NEAL

The utility of the line in question has been greatly diminished by the opening of a new line through Sutton-in-Ashfield in April, 1917, and I am advised that its re-opening for passenger traffic would be uneconomical, besides adding to existing difficulties at Sutton Junction.

Mr. CARTER

Is the hon. Gentleman aware that the closing of this particular line is hampering trade and commerce and inflicting great hardship on the people of the district, who have to walk a mile and a half, and if representations have been made by the public authority in favour of the re-opening of the line?

Mr. NEAL

I am quite aware that this has caused some inconvenience, but the railway companies concerned and the Minister of Transport have to strike a balance as between convenience and inconvenience and expense.

Mr. CARTER

Will the hon. Gentleman further investigate the matter and ascertain the views of the inhabitants?

Mr. NEAL

I shall be very glad to consider any representations my hon. Friend brings to my notice.