HC Deb 08 July 1920 vol 131 c1668
Viscount CURZON (by Private Notice)

asked the Secretary of State for War whether, prior to the decision of the Army Council with reference to General Dyer having been arrived at, he was tried by a military tribunal, and, if he has the right to such a trial, would such a trial be granted if he desired it?

Mr. CHURCHILL

The only form of military tribunal prescribed is a court-martial. In reply to the second part of the question, the answer is in the negative. Paragraph 470 of the King's Regulations shows that an officer has no right to demand a court-martial upon himself.

Mr. SHORT

Did the General appear before the Army Council in person?

Mr. CHURCHILL

No, Sir, but in view of the fact that the whol of this afternoon is going to be given to the Debate on this subject, it seems rather a pity to carry it on by question and answer.

Mr. C. PALMER

Did this gallant General ask for a military inquiry, as distinct from a court-martial?

Mr. CHURCHILL

No, Sir.

Sir E. CARSON

Is there any way in which he can have a fair trial before he is finally broken, after 34 years' service?

Mr. CHURCHILL

I really think that that is a matter which can better be dealt with in Debate.