HC Deb 20 November 1919 vol 121 cc1136-7
89. Sir HENRY COWAN

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer whether, having regard to a statement made by him on 5th November to the effect that he would be glad to consider any suggestions from the House for effecting economies, he will indicate the method by which he would propose that such suggestions should be conveyed to him?

Mr. BALDWIN

It is not unusual for hon. Members to memorialise Ministers in favour of increased expenditure in particular cases. If the hon. Member can succeed in obtaining equally widely signed memorials in favour of curtailing expenditure by reducing or suspending particular services as suggested in his previous question, my right hon. Friend will be glad to give them his most friendly consideration.

Mr. BILLING

Will the hon. Gentleman consider the advisability of putting a suggestions box in the Lobby?

90. Mr. LAMBERT

asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer if he is aware of the growing exasperation of those classes who are being crushed by war burdens and high cost of living, and at the extravagance illustrated at auction sales, motor shows, and the like; and whether he can devise taxation whereby some extravagant people can assist the taxpayer out of their superfluous wealth?

Mr. BALDWIN

My right hon. Friend has not been able to devise, nor, he thinks, have others been able to suggest, a, luxury tax which would be either effective for this purpose or fair in its application.