HC Deb 15 July 1919 vol 118 cc189-90
18. Major CHRISTOPHER LOWTHER

asked the Secretary of State for War whether his attention has been called to a speech made by Field-Marshal Sir Douglas Haig at Newcastle, on 8th July, in which he made critical remarks as to the efforts of our Allies in the War; and whether he can see his way to advise officers on the active list to refrain in public speeches from making statements derogatory to our Allies and associates?

Mr. CHURCHILL

I have not seen any full report of the speech in question, but I am sure that there was no intention on the part of Sir Douglas Haig to depreciate the efforts of our Allies. Indeed, it appears from the summarised accounts that his object was simply to show how heavy was the burden successfully borne by the British Army.

Major LOWTHER

Will the right hon. Gentleman answer the second part of the question?

Mr. CHURCHILL

I think that part does not arise. I say I am sure there was no intention on the part of Sir Douglas Haig to depreciate the efforts of our Allies.

Major LOWTHER

Does the right hon. Gentleman not see that the second part of the question does not necessarily refer to Sir Douglas Haig, but is of general application?

Mr. CHURCHILL

I think it is quite unnecessary to issue any general instruction to officers not to make speeches which are derogatory to our Allies.