HC Deb 05 August 1919 vol 119 c169
67. Sir RICHARD COOPER

asked the Prime Minister if Mr. Justice Sankey, before his elevation to the bench, had held the position of standing counsel to the Miners' Federation; and was this fact brought to his notice when he asked Mr. Justice Sankey to preside over the recent Coal Commission?

Mr. BONAR LAW

I am unaware whether or not the suggestion contained in the question represents the facts; but I am quite certain that the inuendo which it contains against the impartiality of a Judge of the Realm ought not to be made.

Sir R. COOPER

Is it not in the public interest that rumours which have got very widespread should be crushed by hon. Members asking deliberate questions on the matter?

Mr. BONAR LAW

No; but I think it is in the public interest that Members of this House should do their best not to spread, but to crush such rumours.

Mr. W. CARTER

Is the right hon. Gentleman aware that questions of that kind usually come out of the minds of men who judge of the character and honour of other people by their own?