HC Deb 19 March 1917 vol 91 cc1541-2
50. Mr. W. THORNE

asked the Prime Minister whether he is in a position to announce the decision of the War Cabinet in the matter of trade card exemptions?

Dr. ADDISON

My right hon. Friend has asked me to reply to this question. My hon. Friend will appreciate that the fullest consideration must be given to a matter of this importance, and that it will be necessary to consult the trade unions concerned. I am afraid that I am not at present in a position to make any further statement, but I hope to be able to do so at an early date.

Mr. THORNE

Will the right hon. Gentleman advise the War Office not to call up any men who have signed form MM 81 until this question is settled?

Dr. ADDISON

I am afraid I cannot answer a comprehensive question like that.

Mr. PRINGLE

Can the right hon. Gentleman promise that a statement shall be made in the course of this week?

Dr. ADDISON

No, I am afraid it will not be possible to do so.

Mr. CLYNES

Is the right hon. Gentleman aware that the grievance underlying this question has existed since the middle of December, and that representations have been made repeatedly to the War Office, to the Munitions Ministry, and to other State Departments, and may I ask him whether, if the matter is not to be settled at an early date, he will undertake to receive further representations from the various trade unions who are aggrieved?

Dr. ADDISON

I am well aware of the matters referred to by my hon. Friend. The card system, however, was introduced some time in January, so the grievances could not arise before that time. We are endeavouring to deal with this matter as expeditiously as possible, and we are proposing to call a meeting of the unions concerned as soon as a convenient date can be fixed and these proposals are ready to put before them. We cannot discuss it until we have met the unions.

Mr. PRINGLE

May we take it then, that the statement in the "Times" that this system has been put an end to is totally unauthorised and untrue?

Dr. ADDISON

Nothing has been decided.

Mr. THORNE

Will the right hon. Gentleman when he calls his conference not only call the trade unions together who are aggrieved, but also delegates representing the general labourers' unions as well?

Dr. ADDISON

It is obvious, I think, that all the unions concerned will be consulted finally. I think, however, it is desirable in the first place to discuss the proposed modifications with the unions that were parties to the existing agreement.

Mr. CLYNES

Is it not rather more important to discuss the matters with the unions that are aggrieved?

Dr. ADDISON

We shall be delighted to discuss it with those unions as well. I think, however, it is more businesslike to proceed in the way I have indicated.

Mr. PRINGLE

Does the right hon. Gentleman not think it desirable to have a frank discussion in this House?

Dr. ADDISON

I think I have in this matter given the frankest possible reply.