HC Deb 14 March 1916 vol 80 cc1858-9
21. Sir COURTENAY WARNER

asked the Under-Secretary of State for War if he is aware that in many cases recruiting officers have persuaded men who had been rejected as medically unfit to give up their certificates and insisted on attesting them; if this is contrary to their instructions; and if the Secretary of State for War will remove and otherwise punish these recruiting officers for failing to carry out the instructions and illegally compelling men to attest?

Mr. TENNANT

I do not think that there is any general practice of the kind suggested, though cases have been brought to my notice. It is certainly not in accordance with instructions, but I cannot undertake the drastic act on suggested unless it should appear that there was really ground for it.

Sir C. WARNER

Has any action been taken in cases where rules have been broken? Surely the right hon. Gentleman must see that it is a very important question?

Mr. TENNANT

If it can be really brought home that a recruiting officer has deliberately disobeyed instructions, then suitable action will be taken.

Mr. ANDERSON

Is the right hon. Gentleman aware that since he made his statement in this House certificates have been and are still being torn up, that many unfit men are being treated with great harshness, and that some recruiting officers say the Under-Secretary of State for War has no authority in this matter?

Mr. TENNANT

No, Sir, I am not aware of any one of those three things, and, if my hon. Friend will bring to my notice the actual case of a particular officer, I will certainly have it inquired into.

Mr. PRINGLE

Is my right hon. Friend aware that notices mobilising these men are still being issued?

Mr. OUTHWAITE

Will my right hon. Friend take steps to punish the offenders?

Mr. SPEAKER

I would remind hon. Members of the great number of questions which we have upon the Order Paper.