HC Deb 02 January 1913 vol 46 cc526-7
61. Sir WILLIAM BYLES

asked the Home Secretary whether, seeing that the Home Office so frequently overrides the Law by refusing to execute a capital sentence pronounced by the Courts, almost invariably so in the case of female criminals, he will see his way to extend a like clemency to all male offenders under sentence of death who have not yet reached the age of manhood nor assumed the duties and responsibilities of citizenship?

Mr. McKENNA

The answer is in the negative. Neither I nor my predecessors have thought it desirable to lay down a hard and fast rule such as my hon. Friend suggests.

Sir W. BYLES

Will the consideration which leads to clemency in the case of women also apply to immature youths like those mentioned in my question?

Mr. McKENNA

No, Sir. In the great bulk of the cases in which clemency has been extended to women, the murder has been the murder of an infant child.