HC Deb 13 February 1913 vol 48 cc1173-4
51. Mr. FREDERICK WHYTE

asked whether the Office of Works has made any estimate of the cost of removing the Calton Gaol from its present site; whether any search for a new site has been or will be made; and whether the question of an alternative site for the proposed new Government buildings, other than the Calton site, has been considered and decided?

Mr. W. BENN

The removal of the Calton Gaol and the acquisition of a new site is not a matter to be settled by the First Commissioner of Works, and no estimate of the cost of such removal and acquisition has been prepared by him. Another site for the proposed new Government buildings was considered, but the decision was in favour of the Calton Prison site.

Mr. J. HOGGE

Will the hon. Gentleman say where the other site was?

Mr. W. BENN

In St. James' Square.

MARQUESS of TULLIBARDINE

Can the hon. Gentleman give us any particular reason why the hon. Member for East Edinburgh (Mr. J Hogge) should prefer the preservation of a gaol instead of public buildings?

Mr. J. HOGGE

May I say—

Mr. SPEAKER

I deprecate these personal exchanges.