HC Deb 11 August 1913 vol 56 c2049
23. Mr. JAMES HOGGE

asked the Secretary to the Treasury if he will state the estimated total amount of transfer value of members resident in Scotland of the Prudential approved society for men, the Prudential approved society for women, and the National Amalgamated Society, assuming average ages for the purpose?

Mr. BENN

As I informed my hon. Friend on the 6th instant, the necessary data for a proper estimate are not available, and I fear that a calculation on the hypothesis suggested by him would be liable to prove misleading.

Mr. J. HOGGE

Is it not a fact that the Treasury is calculating on the average age now?

Mr. BENN

I am informed that that is not so, and that no reliable information, can be given, except after investigation in each case.

Mr. BOOTH

Is my hon. Friend aware that for all practical purposes the number may be taken at two millions.

Mr. BENN

I will not quarrel with my hon. Friend's estimate.