HC Deb 02 November 1911 vol 30 cc1001-2
Mr. NEWMAN

asked the Prime Minister whether, in the event of separate Exchequers being established for Ireland and Great Britain, the revenue to be contributed by each Exchequer for Imperial expenditure will be based strictly on the estimated true revenue for Ireland and Great Britain, respectively; and whether, in the event of the answer being in the affirmative, he can state the contribution that would be required from Ireland were her contribution based on her estimated average true revenue for the four years 1907–11?

The PRIME MINISTER

No, Sir, I can make no statement on this matter.

Mr. NEWMAN

May I ask the Prime Minister, he himself being a Scottish Member, whether in the event of Home Rule being given to Scotland he would be willing that Scotland should contribute on the same basis?

Mr. SPEAKER

That question does not arise out of the answer.

Mr. OLIVER LOCKER-LAMPSON

asked the Prime Minister whether any communication in regard to Home Rule has been communicated to the Press; and, if so, whether he will make a similar communication to the House?

The PRIME MINISTER

No, Sir.

Captain CRAIG

May we take it that all the statements made by the Nationalists on the subject of Home Rule are the outcome of their own fertile imaginations?

The PRIME MINISTER

I was asked "whether any communication in regard to Home Rule has been communicated to the Press," and my answer was in the negative.

Captain CRAIG

May I ask if it has been made to the Nationalist Members?

The PRIME MINISTER

No.

Captain CRAIG

Then, it has not.