HC Deb 31 May 1911 vol 26 c1051
Mr. ASHLEY

asked how many armoured ships were under construction for the British and German Fleets respectively on 31st March, 1904, and how many on the same date in the present year?

Mr. McKENNA

The figures asked for are:—Great Britain: On 31st March, 1904, twenty-one (excluding "Swiftsure" and "Triumph"); on 31st March, 1911, fourteen. Germany: On 31st March, 1904, eight; on 31st March, 1911, twelve.

Mr. ASHLEY

Are we to understand that if we exclude the two ships which are being constructed our ships and those of Germany which are being constructed are on an equality?

Mr. McKENNA:

No; the hon. Member wishes to draw an inference which contains a fallacy. The hon. Member must remember that the British ships only take twenty-four months to build and the German ships thirty-six to forty, and, consequently, the fact that the same number are building does not mean that the two countries are only making the same naval preparations.

Mr. ASHLEY

asked how many completed battleships of 10,000 tons and over, and not more than ten years launched there were in the British and German navies, respectively, on 31st March, 1904; and what are the corresponding figures for the same date this year?

Mr. McKENNA

The figures asked for are: Great Britain.—On 31st March, 1904, 30; on 31st March, 1911, 24. Germany.—On 31st March, 1904, 10, on 31st:March. 1911, 18.